Existential vs Essential

Reconciling Existentialism (Personality) with Essentialism (Essence/Soul)

By Stephen Cocconi

“Man first of all exists, encounters himself, surges up in the world—and defines himself afterwards. The more positive, therapeutic aspect of this is also implied: a person can choose to act in a different way, and to be a good person instead of a cruel person.”  Lecture Existentialism is a Humanism – by John Paul Sartre

For those of you who are students of metaphysics, religion, philosophy or simply personal exploration for navigating life, you are being alerted here to one of the fundamental paradoxes about human existence: if you are/have an eternal soul, then why should we worry about a specific incarnation? In Michael Teaching speak: the quality of a Personality’s individual life.

This pits the concept of Existentialism i.e. this is the only life you have and who you are/is a function of your own mind. Versus that of Essentialism i.e. the Platonic view that some preexisting attributes form the character of an individual. This latter view is a foundational assumption of the Michael Teachings’ in the concepts of Role and Overleaves. And the additional innate context of Soul Age as process underpinning, though changing frame-of-reference, internally shaping the way Role and Overleaves are perceived and expressed. Each category is preternatural to the formation of a Personality. But these are both suggested ‘metaphysical[1]’ arguments about human origins and existence. Biology, however, with emphasis on both genetic inheritance and, more recently “epigenetics” at least offer a physical explanation of how we become the persona we will express not merely shaped by environment or decisions.

What if both concepts are interwoven and not in conflict? What that would assume is that there is “metaxis[2]” between our corporeal life and some disembodied state of ‘spiritual’ existence. In Michael Teaching terminology, our Physical Plane personhood in mortal life is our Personality (conscious Psyche) that is augmented by Ego identities (to deal with the interactions with other people in pursuit of getting survival needs acquired.) Yet this acknowledgment of how a human life exists and progresses attributes the combined influence or blueprint to an Essence, or Soul, that is continuous beyond the confines of death, and the complex interaction of experiences (conditioning, social shaping (imprinting), and societal placement (economic, racial, historical, geographic) and asserts that together this wide expanse of influences and circumstances ALL create a human being’s expression in a lifetime.

WOW! I know, right? These concepts DO NOT have to be mutually exclusive, but if one explores each factor, when investigating themselves with conscious deliberation, the answers you learn can deepen the quantity of knowledge with also improve quality of self-awareness. So too, the opposite stands true: avoidance or unconscious deflection of these influences, still renders a Homo Sapien, they act as mere automatons of the social genotype they have been born into, and not with an autonomous agency that interacts with life, but merely reacts to it.

And, implied within this last statement, is the subtext for the theory and structure of Soul Aging. That with each additional incarnation, (which yes means re-incarnation) but does NOT mean transmigration of a Self – which is a single personality, but rather a reintegrated and expanded Essence comprised of information and experiences derived from all combined incarnations but not repeating the same identity or persona from a previous one. (There is no “eternal recurrence”.)

Thus, if you have happened upon this site, you will be or have been looking through this material, but you might also have knowledge of other philosophical systems, this brief essay is meant as an explanation, a foundation, and welcome for you to explore this material. And, as an individual agent of your own life, making decisions about yourself and the world you occur in, then know that the foundation of this broad large language model is this: YOU CHOOSE! Whether the subject choosing is Essence, Personality or Ego; and whether or not there is knowledge of it or self-awareness against with may have meta-cognition. Which heretofore, this is my iteration of the Orthodox Michael Teachings (OMT), the one I have broadened and included more historically diverse but relevant investigations into the human condition. I term it the Applied Michael Approach (AMA) on the sister web site www.appliedmichael.com emphasizing using self knowledge in service to the world and not simply one’s own investigations.

No one need be here, read, nor evaluate any of this material’s concepts or my interpretations. But if you do, please realize that an absolute condition of human agency is that you invariably decide what is “true” for you. That, by my definition is the direction toward where we as a race must travel: to the domain of the humane being, and we can only reach there as our true adult selves. So get going!

I hope you enjoy your explorations of this site and of the Michael Teachings. Axios!


[1] Metaphysical is any and all explanation that happen ‘meta = above, invisible, behind or beneath’ material or physical reality.

[2] A term coined by Plato to speak about the interconnectedness between states of being, and they being in continuous motion (like in choices between polarities.) Yet, the definition has been employed by more contemporary writers to include the simultaneous existence on two autonomous states or planes of existence.